357 magnum vs 30 06

no just the 627 almost the same gun so he used that one, and i agree with that choice. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. Personally, I like the stainless steel version since it handles moisture better than blued steel. If price is of no concern nor is nationality, how could the Rhino be left out? These revolvers weigh between 25 to 60 ounces empty. My 2nd revolver was a Rhino. no gun is a must as its all in the opinion of the person who makes the liks. By the way, whats wrong with the Taurus? If I could only have one revolver off this list, it would be the GP100. "Since more of the bullets mass is outside the cartridge, there is more room for powder in the cartridge." Printing is a challenge. Doesn't make a very good concealed carry firearm. Yes, the 357 really comes alive out of a rifle. Toll-Free: . Be sure to read all about the K6s in our review! NO!!! Answer (1 of 13): The 30-30 is more powerful and has a longer effective range, particularly with pointy polymer tipped bullets it can be a reliable 225-250 yard deer rifle. You wont find one off the shelf, but I could take a standard 9mm barrel and find a good lathe operator to deepen the chamber. However, the highest-cost for the 9mm Luger was $1.95, while the highest per-round price for .357 Magnum was $1.90. It has been for going one 30 or 40 years. This post was originally published in 2011. 1. I would love to put a python in your hand for a spin at the range you wound need a roll of paper towels after making a mess in your trousers. I still regularly take it to the range and it is very accurate and can handle a heavy load with no problem. The .357 Magnum Winchester PDX1 Defender JHP with 125-grain bullets costs $1.25 per round, while the same product ( 125 grain JHP) for .357 SIG cost $1.10 per round. yup both these come in 4inch 5 and 6 the 627 is better than the 686. The utility of the .357 Magnum round makes it just as pleasing for experienced shooters. Purchased this gun in 1985 and have never had a single problem with it. If I gotta have a second choice, It's gunna be Ruger or "Other" SAR that can handle .357 Mag rounds. The combination of a sealed breech and long barrel really brings the efficient little cartridge to life, and it can safely be loaded up to 30-30 . And the Ruger GP100 7-shot with 4 barrel. However, theres the Marlin 336 and the Savage 99. A little game where each player hits the soda can while its still moving. Short summary: .30-30 is a rifle cartridge. If your gun is likely to be used primarily for recreational shooting, hunting medium game within 100 yards, or defensive use, the .357 is superior. Mostly it's concealed but not totally. I want a levergun in .357 mag so bad, Im waiting for a production lever gun in .357 Max, got money on the table. Stay safe and be good with your aim.. GP100 .357 Magnum #1702 Details. It became quite widely utilized in .30-06 is an fantastic cartridge, but it's hard to argue with the statistics. Now thats a good reply right there.hehe.. That comparison isnt even good enough to be called lame. Probably, the better compromise is a bullet that holds together at rifle velocity even though it will be just a solid slug at revolver velocity. Im also a novice who is grateful for the information & the personal opinions/experiences in the comments. I keep my .30-30 loaded with Federal 125gr. The S&B 158-grain JSPs gave carbine numbers of 1451 fps and 739 lb-ft, but the chrono battery died before we could measure them from the revolver. No one can argue that the Colt Python, an out-of-production .357 revolver, has to be on any list of "best" .357s, but if you open the list to guns that no longer are in production, you have to abide by that decision. However, the .380 does a good job with shot placement. Lets talk a little about the various frame sizes you can expect to see when shopping. Colt Lawman Mark III This standard (.30-06) length magnum cartridge drives a 250 grain bullet at a muzzle . Back in the day, it was, by far, the absolute best out-of-the-box revolver on the marketPERIOD!! The 15-2 is still available on the used market and at a reasonable price. soft . That was the only issue I've ever had. A relative newcomer in comparison to some of these models, the Kimber K6s comes in a few different models with the main two being the standard K6s (Double-action only), and the DASA (exposed hammer). The SAAMI specs call for a .355 groove diameter and a .346" bore diameter. you a link to reset your password. It may be pretty weak sauce compared to more modern, high-velocity rounds, but it still gets the job done for most game at reasonable ranges. What the hell is that!!Usually so,meone else answer s for me. The King Cobra is a medium-frame 6-shot revolver with a 3-inch barrel, sporting a brushed stainless steel finish. It was first introduced in 1934 and serves as the foundation of the Magnum Era.. You must not know about them yet. cases were difficult to load with light loads in the early days due to *excessive* volume. I own the .357 with a 4.2" barrel and its very nice. I also owed a Ruger Blackhawk w/6 1/2 barrel. If the ball collides with them, slope io game is over. The only problem with it was the grip was too small. Barrel lengths differ based on which model but most float between 2 and 4 inches. Now what should we compare it to. Easy to conceal carry, highly accurate and heavy enough to handle full power loads. Powerful. Pure and simple. Another dumb comment about this dumb article. While both rounds work well for self-defense, the 357 Magnum kicks ass in the realm of hunting. Theres nothing to stop a hand loader from using slow powder to maximize velocity out of a 9 mm carbine. I purchased a new Kimber K6s and a new S&W 640 Pro last month. I sure tames the recoil, but I didn't care for the trigger. Excellent price too. Buffalo Bore also claims that their Heavy .357 Magnum hard cast 158-grain loads will produce 2153 fps and 1626 lb-ft from an 18 carbine. When and if I get some of these to test Ill post the results, but for big game Id still rather have a .30-30. 66ss , 2 1/2 brl. They could carry one caliber for two weapons. My friend retired as a Lt. It comes factory-tuned from S&W with a few extra features like a fiber-optic front sight and an even smoother trigger. Detailed specs plus plain language observations show Mr Dumm takes his work seriously. It's easy to build muscle memory of draw, clear, finger on trigger, pull hammer and then trigger, repeat. . The .38 Special case has plenty of volume. Penetration: 18.1 The EAA Windicator* .38/.357 magnum from European American Armoury is an excellent choice not mentioned here.especially for those on a bit of a budget. are many fine cartridges out there but, I'm still Kinber revolvers from now on for me. Compare. Not laughingsaw a trick shot guy using a Rossi as this main gun. In other words, sure - a Bugatti is one of the pinnacles of cars. When I hear .357 Magnum, I immediately think, "COLT PYTHON"!!! This gun is FABULOUS! Our .357 Magnum pistol: a 1980s Smith & Wesson Model 686 with a 4 barrel. Always has been. I loaded it myself using 180 grain bullets and Hodgkins h110 powder. Re: 357 vs 44 mag vs 44-40 popularity in lever guns . Sounds like youre the target audience for an article detailing why the 300 AAC Blackout rifle cartridge is ballistically superior and much more powerful than 9mm handgun ammo. Uh, couple more you left out, Charter Arms, Chiappa, Wesson Arms, etc. The S&W 627 Prois an 8-shot .357 Magnum DA/SA. Hunting distances will be well inside 150 yards. 30-30 Winchester; 30-06 Springfield; 308 Winchester; 50 Beowulf; 5.45x39; 7mm Remington Magnum; 7mm-08 Remington; 7.62x39; 7.62x54R; . Additionally, the .327 Magnum revolver will not only be easier to shoot faster and more accurately, but it will also hold . Too funny! It is black and I put a optic on it but I really want the nebula color because it's different. Model 27. Did anyone mention the ugly one"Chiappa Rhino? So Im deciding to use CLP and an air gun in the near future to clean it. Comparing full power .357 SIG to watered-down .357 Magnum ammo is an apples to oranges comparison. OTOH, my remaining 357, a very low mileage 4" Python in Colt Royal Blue, makes me feel better. It is available in blued and stainless steel finishes and a variety of barrel lengths with the 4.2-inch and 6-inch offerings being the most popular. 200 yards is really the only accuracy I'm looking for. Thanks! i harvest a very old white nosed buck with a .357 and my 30-06 in kentucky during modern firearm season. While the .357 Magnum from a carbine does not quite match the .30-30 Win in velocity or energy, at 50 yards all of the loads mentioned in this article approach or exceed the 900 ft/lbs of energy . Watch out! 60. I think the rhino has it won hands down ,design reduces recoil ,still shoot my pythons and a bunch of distinguished combat magnums by s& w but the rhino is my favorite because of reduced recoil. You pretty much have to hunt in a manner that gives you a very accurate shot. The reason to have a rifle in .357 is to be able to shoot the same ammunition out of both guns. For uses other than big-game hunting, .357 Magnum carbines have other benefits which have nothing to do with ballistics. They show that the .357 Mag is far and away the most popular with close to the total votes. But I will put them up against any of your listed for accuracy, reliability, looks, and just plain Ol' fashioned "Cool Factor". The recoil is very mild. There have been discussions in the past about the comparison between the .357 Magnum and the .30 Carbine cartridges. Hornady Leverevolution web page. In the words of Gunblast writer Jeff Quinn Quote: " The 357 Magnum out of a carbine barrel is a whole different animal than the same cartridge fired from a four or six inch revolver. Long live the mighty K frame. Anything further is just gravy. I have owned 2 Model 66s (6 shot), with 4 barrels and a 2 Model 606 (not 605). The Security Six has the best reviews of all 357 Mag. In cooler carry my Windy in what you might call "semi-open" OWB carry, under a jacket or vest. While these guns are powerful, their large size and heavy weight make them harder to conceal. Carried OWB people can definitely notice you have a gun if closely observing or if your jacket opens up a little bit which is why I mention different carry gfuns for different situations. . The problem with reviews of the BEST .357 Magnum revolvers is that the reviewers tend to be in the pockets of the advertisers. I regret selling my S&W 586. and then theres the marlin .444. The 357 Magnum and Colt Python revolver partnership is legendary in target competition with ragged one-hole results, at 50-yards . It's chambered in nearly every major manufacturer's rifle and has a plethora of ammunition choices as well. .357 Mag ammo from brands like Hornady, Federal, and CCI. Thanks for the informative charts on the S&W models and Ill have to check out their 8 round revolver that I didnt know existed! And if you do that, you should consider all the giants upon whose shoulders today's manufacturers stand. But it's in my safe and I carry a semi auto due to available firepower with a .357 Sig - in a 226 - can't beat the ballistics Really great article. (, We noticed that you have previously logged in with your, Check what do you get by creating an account, Bookmark and compare your favorite firearms, 8 Best .357 Magnum Revolvers [Proven Stopping Power]. Keep 'em coming. From a concealed carry standpoint, the .327 Federal Magnum will give you slightly less effective terminal performance when compared to the .357, but similar and even better performance when compared to .38 Special +P ammo. Then, as now, everyone wanted more powerful ammo. Thank y'all! You want J frame size 6 shots get a Kimber K6S they are excellent out of the box, You didnt even mention the model 19? I enjoyed reading y'all's comment. .30-30 vs .357 Magnum at The Truth About Guns. Developed for use by French police and Special Weapons and Tactics units and fielded by the French GIGN, the accuracy and durability of this revolver are legendary. To simulate the carry .357 Magnum ammo, use .38 Special +P or low velocity .357 Magnum ammo. Size Difference Between 30.06 vs 308. For pythons now. As a pacifist, I have always tried to avoid violence in all forms. But man what a smooooth double action trigger. It's a shame and you're not doing anyone a service. I would like to get ahold of a Smith & weightWesson 357 Magnum with 8 and 3/8 inch barrel. The extra length prevents the revolvers cylinder from closing and locking into place. So work of art for a operating gun not a collector that sits and never ever will it get packed ! Shes a beauty and she cooks! I love me a Glock / AR combo, but if I could have only one set for the rest of my life, itd be a wheelgun/carbine set in .44 Mag (first choice) or .357 Mag (second option). I think it was for their 50 year of operation. The Kimber feels beefier, it is finished better than any gun for the money. Thanks for reading! Hornady claims that they make 2400 fps from a 24 test barrel, and I was pleasantly surprised that the Trappers 16 barrel (literally one-third shorter) only paid a small 11.25 percent velocity penalty. I had a GP-100 and loved it. I too have a GP 100 and a S&W 686 Plus. That was way back in '89. These were both brand new 640 revolvers and even the "good" one was not that great. There are NO sharp edges anyhwere and it comes in 2, 3 & 4 inch barrels. I suppose articles like this are of great importance for the simple minded who are clueless theres a huge difference between rifle and pistol ammunition and have never taken the time to read the specific ballistic data printed right on new ammunition boxes containing 30-30 or 357 cartridges, or notice that 30-30 brass is a lot BIGGER than 357 mag brass, or are oblivious to the abundance of ballistic info 101 that can be accessed online in seconds. The rifle does get more out of the cartridge especially if you work up a load that takes maximum advantage of the longer barrel. If you can find a Security Six in good condition, Buy it. If you don't own one, you should. mitigates recoil and muzzle lift. purchase helps support my work in bringing you more awesome gun and gear articles. I couldnt measure their velocity from the revolver, because theyre so smoky and sooty that the flying particles gave false readings from the chronograph. 06-30-2009 @ 12:56 AM Location Houston Texas Posts 189 Local Date 01-15-2023 Local Time 05:16 AM.30 Carbine vs .357 Magnum There have been discussions in the past about the comparison between the .357 Magnum and the .30 Carbine cartridges. It's also worth doing a trigger job to reduce the heavy and jerky pulls for both SA and DA. Generally I never shoot the gun in DA, as a matter personal preference and much better accuracy. The S&W model 19 and SS version 66 was/is one of the best law enforcement sidearms of all time. My longest shot was approximately 123 yard shooting a souped up Hornady xtp round. Practice with light .357 Magnum ammunition to simulate heavier loads. I definitely want to own a dan wesson one day. The .357s handgun ballistics are impressive indeed, but how much more impressive does it get from an extra fourteen inches of barrel? Effective. This statement in the article is incorrect, "the .357 Magnum round also needed a 1/8 inch longer case to hold more gunpowder." I have a 4" GP100 match champion that shoots like a dream. The Trooper was a steal as someone didn't know what they had. The 27-2 is very nice. .357 Magnum could work too for hunting, especially in a rifle vs. a revolver, but going with .30-30 would give you a bit more edge . While heavier than the standard Colt Cobra, the extra weight helps tame the recoil of the .357 Magnum cartridge and increases service life. This conclusion will undoubtedly anger many who presently hunt deer with a 357 or 44 mag, but the numbers don't lie. Closest to the Taurus. Just stopping a threat does not mean the gun has "proven Stopping Power" Ruger SP101, 3-inch barrel. My service arm was a Ruger Security 6. Rossi 92 .357 lever . I dont shoot it much, but for me its still a keeper. Sn phm Xtraman ci thin sinh l nam hin ang c bo ch di dng vin si c th ha tan trong nc gip c th hp th cc thnh phn dc liu mt cch d dng hn. For general target practice, shoot .38 Special ammo. The very first gun I ever bought was a Taurus Model 66, 357 mag. Slightly less recoil and significantly greater savings gives this round to the .25-06 Remington. After 35 years this one is still my favorite. Some private citizens still use K Frames for self-defense, target shooting, and hunting, but theyre pretty obsolete. Tried a few different grips but not a lot of selection for that model, but it deserves to be on there being the first revolver with the transfer bar. The 350 legend is actually a 9mm not the same as a 357. I know we all have our answers to this. Min Expansion: 0.587. The .357 Sig is perhaps the most common one not a "magnum". I have 9's 45's but the revolver is my favorite to shoot. With 9mm there's barely any detectable recoil. And I like that some loads, like Buffalo Bore 180 grain equals or surpasses standard.30-30 loads under 200 or so yards. The blow back system is under a LOT of pressure. With higher-performance loads, the .357 carbine almost delivers real rifle ballistics. For target practice, I still recommend using .38 Special ammo to save money. Aside from being much more powerful, the .357 Magnum round also needed a 1/8-inch longer case to hold more gunpowder. You might want to check it out for future reviews and lists. Rate it below! Chiappa Rhino should be on this list. The GP-100, Redhawk, and SP-101 would later follow. The first of the Magnum pistol cartridges, it was a big hit. Looking closely I believe the problem was the previous owner had flipped the wheel into the gun with a flick of the hand quite a few times causing the damage (NEVER do this with your revolver despite it being a rather satisfying feeling and it being ubiquitous in the movies.) Your article states the S&W K frame is obsolete. The only thing that I regret in hindsight is 35 years ago having a custom trigger and hammer job done on the Mod. Have a 44mag revolver, and two 44mag carbines. It's soft shooting even with 357 magnum rounds. Even the little .243 Winchester throwing a 100-grain bullet 3,100 fps cranks out more muzzle energy2,100 ft-lbsthan the .30-30. Clean and mean. Moreover, you also need to be careful when the ball goes through the tunnel. Weve built dozens of ARs and well cover all the best AR-15 upgrades such as handguards, triggers, BCGs, gas blocks, and more. Our .30-30: an early-1990s Winchester Model 1894 'Trapper' with a 16.5 barrel. Yowza. We normally include at least one high-end option, partly for perspective and partly because they are nice to look at. And thats with standard ammo. Despite the fact that some people dont like Taurus guns, I still like my Taurus 617Ti. Currently they sell for 3-5k USD. 30-06 Springfield 30-30 Winchester.308 Winchester 338 Lapua Magnum 5.56x45mm NATO 5.7x28mm 6mm Creedmoor 6.5 Creedmoor 6.5 Grendel 7.62x51mm NATO 7.62x39 Rimfire Ammo 17 HMR 22 Long Rifle On the plus side, these guns can handle large amounts of heavily loaded .357 Magnum ammunition. I have always thought the M1 carbine was a good idea at the time for its intended purpose. Only an idiot would need to read an article to grasp and understand that ANY 30-30 rifle cartridge is vastly more powerful and ballistically superior to ANY 357 magnum cartridge. I lust for lever but I have so many other guns ahead of it! Chuck Hawks rifle ballistics table Although this is the lightest revolver on the list, the high build quality and excellent shootability are apparent in the K6s. The problem with 9mm is youre not gonna get any farther than Blue Dot really; Youre maxed out for burn slowness. Those Remington 125gr. Marcus! Came with two 7 chamber cylinders. With 125-grain handloads, the revolver averaged an even 1300 feet per second and 469 pound-feet of energy, while the carbine delivered 1937 fps and 1041 lb-ft. Thats a 49 percent velocity increase and a 122 percent increase in energy from the same cartridge. Its delightfully accurate, and has never choked on any loads 38 or 357. The results are: . For the .257, that number drops down to 11, and only a few companies produce the cartridge. You'll now receive newsletters of our best articles on techniques, I own 3 of them(One happens to be an "Ashland"). Tested. I tested this actually towards the extremes. You get most of the oomph of 357, but can still conceal easily.